[arguments for longtermism] are based on simple ideas that, impartially considered,
future people should count for no less, morally, than the present generation;
that there may be a huge number of future people;
that life, for them, could be extraordinarily good or inordinately bad;
and that we really can make a difference to the world they inhabit.
... Whether the future is wonderful or terrible is, in part, up to us. What We Owe the Future by William MacAskill
There’s been nothing like this in history. It’s kind of an outrageous statement, but it happens to be true,
that the Republican Party is the most dangerous organization in human history.
Nobody, not even the Nazis, was dedicated to destroying the possibility of organized human life.
It’s just missing from the media. In fact, if you read, say, the sensible business press, the Financial Times, Businessweek,
any of them, when they talk about fossil fuel production, the articles are all just about the prospect for profit.
Is the U.S. moving to number one and what are the gains? Not that it’s going to wipe out organized human life.
Maybe that’s a footnote somewhere. It’s pretty astonishing.
Noam Chomsky
If most of the world’s population truly understood and
appreciated the magnitude of the crises we summarize here, and
the inevitability of worsening conditions, one could logically
expect positive changes in politics and policies to match the
gravity of the existential threats. But the opposite is unfolding.
The rise of right-wing populist leaders is associated with
anti-environment agendas as seen recently for example in
Brazil (Nature, 2018), the USA (Hejny, 2018), and Australia
(Burck et al., 2019). Large differences in income, wealth, and
consumption among people and even among countries render it
difficult to make any policy global in its execution or effect. Underestimating the Challenges of Avoiding a Ghastly Future
What I was saying is that, we are living at a unique moment in the whole history of the human species.
Its seriousness and significance can't be underestimated. You, you and your generation are going to have to make a decision, now,
as to whether organized human life will continue on the earth, that's not an exaggeration.
The environmental crisis is growing, its inexorable, it's not gonna stop.
If concurrent tendencies continue, in your lifetime, that of your children, the prospects for organized human existence will radically decline.
This is not really controversial. Take a look at any issue of the science journals every issue that comes along is a more grim forecast.
Noam Chomsky - speaking to Big Sky High School (Missoula) students about climate change, May 24, 2016
The world will get more crowded. And there´s a second prediction: it will gradually get warmer. Pressures on food supplies, and on the entire biosphere will be aggravated
by the consequent changes in global weather patterns. Climate change exemplifies the tension between the science, the public, and the politicians.
In contrast to population issues, it is certainly not underdiscussed - despite the fact that in
2017 the Trump regime in the United States banned the terms ´global warming´ and ´climate change´ from public documents.
But the implications of climate change are dismayingly under-acted on. Martin Rees, Om the Future, Prospects for Humanity
"The coming years will prove
increasingly cynical and cruel. People will definitely not slip into oblivion while hugging each
other. The final stages in the life of humanity will be marked by the
monstrous war of all against all: the amount of suffering will be
maximal." Pentti Linkola
¨the two ways in which humankind can self-destruct - civil war on a global scale,
or destruction of the natural environment - are rapidly converging¨ Pankaj Mishra, Age of Anger: A History of the Present
(quoted in America, the Farewell Tour by Chris Hedges p179)
It seems relevant that the walled city where the wealthy few live in relative luxury while the masses outside war with one another for survival is pretty much the default premise of every dystopian sci-fi movie that gets made these days, from
“The Hunger Games,” with the decadent Capitol versus the desperate colonies, to
“Elysium,” with its spa-like elite space station hovering above a sprawling and lethal favela. It's a vision deeply enmeshed with the dominant Western religions, with their grand narratives of great floods washing the world clean and a chosen few selected to begin again. It's the story of the great fires that sweep in, burning up the unbelievers and taking the righteous to a gated city in the sky. We have collectively imagined this extreme winners-and-losers ending for our species so many times that one of our most pressing tasks is learning to imagine other possible ends to the human story in which we come together in crisis rather than split apart,
take down borders rather than erect more of them: Naomi Klein, No Is Not Enough: Resisting Trump's Shock Politics and Winning the World We Need,
www.noisnotenough.org
As most IPCC scientists privately expect warming >3C, they expect humans will die off
IPCC lead author (J. Steinberger): -"3 degrees is mass death for sure" -"At 3C warming...anything resembling organised society will have broken down" -"Beyond 2C, adaptation is not feasible" 🧵 https://t.co/HWWfi20Bkx
— Civilization collapse technician Keenan Roberts (@HowKeen) August 27, 2023
Earth daily 2-m Surface Temperature is now 16,99°C this is soo crazy and the silence in media even more I can not handle this anymore! We all feel it something profound has changed. Also look at this massive Anomaly in the Antarctic it is just crazy. Soon we all will be silenced. pic.twitter.com/45g1l3oCSB
Right wing, authoritarian states have a lot in common.
They ally and admire each other and form a new axis, just as Trump consulted with Orban,
Bolsanaro, called Putin
a genius, and benefited him a lot.
We are backsliding toward a repressive totalitarian global regime,
a new world order.
The GOP,given the chance, will collapse the republic similar to 1933 Wiemar.
Armed vigilantes will roam the streets, intimidate political oppositions, police in battle gear.
They clamp down on media, education, use religion
to muddy the truth, discourage critical thinking, and deny science.
Loyal oligarchs are appointed to high office. Corruption is rampant.
Much of this already happened under Trump, but it can get worse.
Climate denial will have devastating consequences.
Downsized social programs will result in misery. Elections will be a sham.
Against all warnings, good judgment, and logic, the Congress, at least the House,
is controlled by Republican crazies after the 2022 midterms,
so there will be no chance of overturning disastrous Supreme Court decisions
on women's rights, voting rights, gerrymandering, Citizen's United, gun control, environment protection,
religion, or discrimination.
All unpopular decisions demonstrating weak democracy and the GOP's
terrible path forward.
Large amounts of dark money funded Trump justices of the Supreme Court, which is indebted to powerful interests, will likely do much more damage to democracy. It has agreed to consider that State legislatures can override voters. That will install Republicans in a one party, right wing, state that will look a lot like Hungary. Voters won’t matter much.
Empire building is expensive and it
is no surprise that the US is broke and in
serious debt. Major financial companies are crumbling, but are
propped up by taxpayers. Since Republicans
brought us another gilded age like the 1920's, the result looks a lot like the 1930's again.
To continue to reward their wealthy
backers, Republicans heap further misery on the middle class. See this.
The U.S. and the rest of the world is well beyond carbon budget.
Since population has exceeded
the carrying capacity of the planet,
and some estimates project collapse within a few years.
Climate degradation is visible
and it is rapid. Most major corporations insist that it is harmless to
dump pollutants into the atmosphere, strip
mine, trawl the ocean, destroy the environment. For scientists, Global
warming is not an issue any more. It is an imminent disaster, but main stream media does not
recognize that.
US Government does not respond to the people, nor does it serve them.
Authoritarians keep people distracted, poor, too busy to protest, misinformed, religious, racist, and nationalist.
Say goodbye to the republic. The future will look like Mad Max, Fury Road.
It may seem impossible to imagine that a technologically advanced society could choose, in essence, to destroy itself,
but that is what we are now in the process of doing. Elizabeth Kolbert
"As we are all surely aware, we now face the most
ominous decisions in human history. There are many problems that must
be addressed, but two are overwhelming in their significance:
environmental destruction and nuclear war. For the first time in
history, we face the possibility of destroying the prospects for decent
existence -- and not in the distant future. For this reason alone, it
is imperative to sweep away the ideological clouds and face honestly
and realistically the question of how policy decisions are made, and
what we can do to alter them before it is too late." Noam
Chomsky
"It might be a familiar progression, transpiring on
many worlds - a planet, newly formed, placidly revolves around its
star; life slowly forms; a kaleidoscopic procession of creatures
evolves; intelligence emerges which, at least up to a point, confers
enormous survival value; and then technology is invented. It dawns on
them that there are such things as laws of Nature, that these laws can
be revealed by experiment, and that knowledge of these laws can be made
both to save and to take lives, both on unprecedented scales. Science,
they recognize, grants immense powers. In a flash, they create
world-altering contrivances. Some planetary civilizations see their way
through, place limits on what may and what must not be done, and safely
pass through the time of perils. Others, not so lucky or so prudent,
perish." Carl Sagan: Pale Blue Dot
“After ages during which the earth produced harmless
trilobites and butterflies, evolution progressed to the point at which
it has generated Neros, Genghis Khans, and Hitlers. This, however, I
believe is a passing nightmare ; in time the earth will become again
incapable of supporting life, and peace will return. ” Bertrand Russell
Every species of living being, and every specimen of each species, is affecting and modifying the biosphere by its efforts to keep itself alive during its brief lifetime.
However, no pre-hominid species has ever had the power to dominate the biosphere or to wreck it.
On the other hand, when a hominid chipped a stone with the intention of making it into a more serviceable tool, this historic act,
performed perhaps two million years ago, made it certain that, one day, some species of some genus of the hominid family of primate mammals would not merely affect and modify the biosphere,
but would hold the biosphere at its mercy.
Arnold Toynbee, Mankind and Mother Earth .
cutting edge science demonstrates the unsustainability of our current business-as-usual trajectory,
and highlights that without a transition to more viable alternatives, we are in for a rough ride involving more of what we've already seen in the last few years
- escalating social unrest, state-failure, economic crisis, extreme weather, geopolitical tension and conflict.
We can expect food and energy prices to continue to rise and contribute to social volatility as well as intensifying inequality
- and as Beddington and others have warned, we can expect that at some point, a worst case scenario would involve us
facing a systemic convergence of crises that undermines the capacity of our social institutions to deliver critical functions.
Nafeez Ahmed
Jared Diamond wrote about the collapse of earlier
civilizations to great acclaim and brisk sales, in a nimbus of
unimpeachable respectability. The stories he told about bygone cultures
gone to seed were, above all, dramatic. No reviewers or other
intellectual auditors dissed him for suggesting that empires inevitably
run aground on the shoals of resource depletion, population overshoot,
changes in the weather, and the diminishing returns of complexity. Yet
these are exactly the same problems that industrial-technocratic
societies face today, and those of us who venture to discuss them are
consigned to a tin-foil-hat brigade, along with the UFO abductees and
Bigfoot trackers. This is unfortunate but completely predictable, since
the sunk costs in all the stuff of daily life (freeways, malls, tract
houses) are so grotesquely huge that letting go of them is strictly
unthinkable. We're stuck with a very elaborate setup that has no
future; but we refuse to consider the consequences. So messengers are
generally unwelcome. (attributed to James
Howard Kunstler.)
"Everything we learn about life in space makes it clear that we're not going to get
a second chance there." Bill McKibben.
. . . our world is in trouble - right now, at this moment in time,
not is some blurry, fuzzy, distant future that no one cares about because we´ll all be gone by the time the worst, unimaginable
horrors might occur. A world that we have conquered and altered is beginning to turn against us. As a result, we are in trouble.
This is the Way the World Ends, How Droughts and Die-Offs, Heat Waves and Hurricanes are converging on America by Jeff Nesbit.
(pg 264)
The biggest challenge facing humanity is that our political, social, and economic systems are shortsighted. Long-term planning typically
considers years or decades, but the global environmental processes we are now influencing play out over centuries, millennia, or more. We need to instill a sense of
geologic time into our culture and our planning, to incorporate truly long-term thinking into social and political decision making.
Scott L. Wing essay in Living in the Anthropocene.
Scientists' warning: capitalism main cause behind “alarming trends of environmental degradation” which now pose “existential threats to natural systems, economies and societies” - top richest 10% responsible for up to 43% of environmental destruction https://t.co/8KuQdJ32oW
"... either one of the two features apparent in
historical societal collapses —over-exploitation of natural resources
and strong economic stratification— can independently result in a
complete collapse. Given economic stratification, collapse is very
difficult to avoid and requires major policy changes, including major
reductions in inequality and population growth rates. Even in the
absence of economic stratification, collapse can still occur if
depletion per capita is too high. However, collapse can be avoided and
population can reach equilibrium if the per capita rate of depletion of
nature is reduced to a sustainable level, and if resources are
distributed in a reasonably equitable fashion." study
(PDF) sponsored by NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center
"Here's what I've decided: the very least you can do
in your life is figure out what you hope for... What I want is so
simple I almost can't say it: elementary kindness. enough to eat,
enough to go around. The possibility that kids might one day grow up to
be neither the destroyers or the destroyed. That's about it." Animal Dreams:
Barbara Kingsolver
As for the natural world, we must try to restore
wonder there too. We could start with that photograph of the earth. It
may be our last chance. Even now it is being used in geography lessons,
taken for granted by small children. We are the first generation to
have seen it, the last generation to take it for granted. Will we
remember what it meant to us ? How fine the earth looked, dangled in
space ? How pretty against the endless black ? How round ? How very
breakable? How small ? It is up to us to try to experience a sense of
wonder about it that will save it before it is too late. If we cannot,
we may do the final damage in our lifetimes. If we can, we may change
the course of and consequently, the course of evolution, setting the
human lineage firmly on a path toward a new evolutionary plateau. The
Tangled Web: Melvin Konner, 2002: pg 436.
... we are in a race for our lives, as our global
economy, reckless in its use of all resources and natural systems,
shows many of the indicators of potential failure that brought down so
many civilizations before ours. By sheer luck, though, ours has two
features that might just save our bacon: declining fertility rates and
progress in alternative energy. Our survival might well depend on doing
everything we can to encourage their progress. Vested interests,
though, defend the status quo effectively and the majority much prefers
optimistic propaganda to uncomfortable truth and wishful thinking
rather than tough action. It is likely to be a close race. From
Jeremy Grantham, The Fall of Civilizations
"Population growth, resource scarcity, world
accumulation of weapons, and global climate change are all mixed
together, and accelerating and exacerbating each other. It's hard to
know even where to begin to talk about them. The big worry is our need
to acquire and consume resources. The underlying force here is that, as
a species, we keep on needing more of everything, and it has been our
consumption of fossil fuels causing global climate change. It's in the
pursuit of resources that we create armies. I see the nature of our
consuming behaviours as the central issue. If you don't somehow bring
that under control, none of the others will be solvable. If we don't
reduce the consumption of fossil fuels, there is no hope of addressing
global warming, and there is no hope of addressing the plunder of
Africa and the other oil-producing countries. So the nature of our
consuming behaviors, and the kinds of decisions that societies make
about the consumption of resources, is the nub." Michael T
Klare quoted in Loving This Planet, Helen Caldicott pg 195
Today, by the end of 2014, we have come to the
conclusion that humanity cannot be saved because (1) the overshoot and depletion
is far beyond restoration and adaptation, and (2) the people in power
positions are unable and unwilling to recognise and act accordingly.
So we added the "404 fatal error" page, from a nostalgic IT dawn era. Ecoglobe
The Emerging World Order, Its Roots our legacy: Noam Chomsky
Yes Virginia. Our generation IS robbing yours now. Wages are
falling, benefits shrinking, working hours longer, vacation time less,
pensions disappearing, debt increasing personally and at all government
levels, most of the growth rewarded the already wealthy, politics degraded, and the Constitution at risk. (See
The Great Risk Shift: by Jacob Hacker.) By not taking action knowing the threat of climate change, you may face a hostile planet.
Most of the dysfunction of our institutions are caused by
extreme wealth inequality
including Campaign finance, lobbying, corruption, polarization,
political gridlock, corporate predators, media distortion, religious tribalism,
runaway costs in healthcare, pharma, insurance, social pathology, and class
stratification. We are, as a result, unlikely to deal with the challenges: climate change, nuclear
proliferation, overpopulation, or war.
When a wealthy minority governs, it is necessarily authoritarian.
It cannot win elections so it rigs them and uses the courts or even armed intimidation to stay in control.
When it reaches one party rule, it crushes opposition and wins ‘elections’ by acclaim.
A celebrity charismatic leader becomes head of state surrounded by corrupt oligarchs.
There are many examples: Russia, Syria, … The US is well along the authoritarian path,
there is an eerie resemblance to 1933 Germany, so it looks like we’re headed for fascism,
and, failing to heed obvious warnings, much worse climate. Republicans wont allow mitigation.
The kids will face a hostile planet.
The Republican agenda was never
for the people, but always for the Corporations
(That, by definition, is called Fascism.)
In fact: poor social supports, corporate supremacy,
union busting, less job security, outsourcing, greedy CEOs,
shady book-keeping, auditor's collusion, corruption, and crony
capitalism ran rampant. Manufacturing jobs hemorrhaged to third-world
sweat shops in what was called globalization.
(See Naomi Klein's
book "Shock Doctrine".)
You will be competing for third-world wages. You will not earn more
than we did. Bush's appointees to the Supreme Court reliably continued his
policy of corporate supremacy and all but destroyed the republic with Citizen's United. US government no
longer serves the people, it answers to corporations.
Trump made even worse appointments. His tax plan accelerated
wealth inequality, the root of many of our problems.
His cabinet appointments are enemies of the very purpose of their agencies, agency capture is typical for
Republican administrations.
Financial instability will be
evident as the Republican assault on the New Deal continues, energy
prices continue to rise, trade deficits get worse, housing
foreclosures impact the middle class, inflation escalates, and so does
debt. The Fed is out of weapons. The stock market could fall out of
bed. The market is responding to Republican deregulation. Their bank
deregulation, the rollback of Glass-Steagle, was particularly
unwise. Deregulation, regressive tax reform, and
degraded labor rights will decrease financial stability. Because consolidation has produced even
larger institutions too big to fail, the next crisis will likely be
much worse.
The two Bush Presidential elections WERE stolen. (See Conyer's report).
The Federal Elections Commission (FEC) became dysfunctional. Any
candidate that would serve the people (with, for example, peace) was disqualified. Only Kucinich dared
utter such thoughts but he was easily marginalized, kept off the debate
stage, and ridiculed by the main stream media.
Since the Supreme Court ruled to allow
unlimited corporate money into elections with Citizens United, expect the end of any real democracy in the US.
Trump won without the popular vote, is attacking supports for democracy, and will likely end it in the U.S.
Media, already bad, will get
worse. It is a major cause of a culture of violence, toxic
politics, polarization, and of education failure in the US.
The three Republican Commissioners of the FCC decided, with strong Bush
encouragement, to further consolidate media ownership. (Be realistic; every
country manages the news.) Last time they attempted this there was a
massive public outcry, but Bush promised to
veto any Congressional action if there was any attempt to roll back the
new standard. Yet another perk for media moguls. Less foreign
reporting, downsized investigative reporting, new legal obstacles for
reporters, more classified information, less whistleblower protection,
more shock jocks, and more consolidated,
down-sized media. Republicans on the FCC rolled back Net neutrality, a victory for corporations over consumers, and the mechanism to
suppress free speech. The internet is private, which is why you do not have free speech there.
The issues that matter don't get much press: i.e. healthcare, pensions, family leave time,
falling wages, union busting, outsourcing,
offshoring, environmental damage, etc.
What you WILL hear about is deficits, tax
cuts for the wealthy, illegal immigrants,
It is evident that US media keeps people distracted,
exploited, subservient, misinformed, juvenile, ignorant, and angry for
the wrong reasons. Since people don't really have information to make
an informed decision, there can be no democracy.
Don't trust anything you hear from US media,
particularly Fox News or right-wing talk radio.
Religion is media.
Religious fervor from Republican candidates, hate speech from
Republican shock jocks, If they can get you asking the
wrong questions, the answers don't matter. In addition to inciting
anger, Republicans insist that everyone
has a right to carry guns. What could go wrong
with that ?
Federal agencies, under Bush, were
populated with party hacks, and career
civil servants left in disgust. Incompetence was rampant. There won't
be any press for this though. Federal agencies are foxes guarding the
henhouses. Trump cabinet picks are considerably worse than Bush's.
The US economy crashed and is returning
to feudalism because of spectacular income inequality. It will build
walled communities for the affluent, there will be walls along the
borders to keep 'them' out, and there
will be a steady increase in the population of detention camps.
The Republican War on Science
continues to introduce religion into the
public dialog and the classroom. Creationism
will get a hearing. Ideology trumps science.
That's the Republican agenda for
improvement of education. Scandinavian
education is well ahead of us and so is their media.
We have passed peak oil, and without
cheap oil our current lifestyle, food and transportation will be
unsustainable. Climate change will
result in food shortages, drought, volatile
weather events, fisheries collapse, and will leave future generations
with a hostile planet. Population
will need to fall to sustainable levels. This will not be an option. "The 2015 UN global population projections
are alarmingly higher than just over a decade ago." (John Seager)
Expect resource wars, such as we are seeing in the middle
east. The US reached peak oil in the 1970's
and the world probably has reached a peak by now. What's
going to happen when we run out of cheap gas to guzzle.
Infrastructure now appears too expensive to maintain, so it is becoming unsafe.
Without regime change in Washington, it is unlikely that we will deal with important issues.
Discontent with a falling standard of living, fewer good jobs,
a shredded safety net, or serious food shortages can cause a turn to religion, turn many
people violent. Widespread, uncontrolled gun
ownership will have its consequences including militarization of the
police. You will not be safer. Picture the wild west with automatic
weapons. This will cause security to be ratchetted up and a strong man dictator, like Trump.
The military-industrial complex is incredibly profitable, and
it now rules. Massive military budgets,
endless war, militarization of the country will
inevitably produce a national security
state. Civil liberties are collateral
damage. Wiretapping, massive datamining, RFID,
large scale surveillance will inevitability result in a totalitarian state.
Net neutrality will be a distant dream. You can forget about privacy. The Constitution
will be all but meaningless. Corporations
rule. Real government will be done in secret.
The hallmark of a failed state is its unresponsiveness
to its people. The forever war will likely turn nuclear.
The final stage of many empires in
history results in 'strong man' head of state. The President has expanded his power so that he
can now act in secret without the need to
worry about the Geneva Conventions, International
Law on Torture, Habeas Corpus, Posse
Commitatus, and he can freely disappear or assassinate
people even if they are citizens. He does not need to practice 'due process of law'. He is above the
law...and the Roberts Supreme Court
will agree because it will has even more 'conservative justices'.
The Presidency has continued to
accumulate power at the expense of the democratically elected Congress. We appear to be headed for an
imperial Presidency accompanied by forever wars, and an all-consuming effort to build an empire. Like every other empire in history, the
outcome will be serious failure if not destruction.
Congress will not be
able to perform oversight because the 'executive branch' doesn't have
to tell them anything. This means that we no longer have a Constitution. Checks and balances are
history because the President has more power than the King we revolted
against. See fascism.
Because war is profitable expect more
of it. Resource wars will become more frequent as climate change and mass migrations
accelerate. The next war could be on our own
soil and it can be more destructive than any of the past. In any event
our military-Keynsian economy will self destruct.
Some are predicting that Israel will
bomb Iran. (For good reason, the Constitution authorized the Congress the
power to declare War, but, really, what's to
stop any President from doing it ?)
Unless the US abandons its quest for empire, your generation
will sacrifice for endless war for empire,
but, since the US is broke, the empire will not last long. Bush created a lot of ill-will. Obama has not held
anyone to account. Trump policy alienates former democratic allies, reeks of corruption,
extracts wealth from the people, and is the incarnation of bad government.
But wait, it gets worse. CO2 emissions are not nearly slowed enough and will persist
in the atmosphere for centuries. Environmental damage will be catastrophic.
194 countries have signed on to the Paris climate agreement, but the United States, alone, has not.
Actually, the Paris agreement is not sufficient to slow the damage much.
Population overshoot is causing the destruction of the environment.
Republicans are in denial of that too.
NASA climate scientist James Hansen forecast a possible 10-foot rise in
sea levels before the end of the century. One-third of Florida's
population lives below this level, as do more than 700,000 residents of
New York City. So do millions in major coast cities. That would force
evacuation of hundreds of millions. Expect mass migrations from flooded
coasts, storm devastation, deserts or uninhabitable areas. Danger of
nuclear war, particularly between India and Pakistan, will grow.
Grandchildren will find the climate increasingly hostile. The end times
will not be pretty. Republicans will bring it on much faster.
We are breaking the laws of nature and the planet will give us the death penalty. Won't be long.
...we can look forward with confidence to character-building
bankruptcies, picturesque bread riots, thrilling cavalcades of
splendidly costumed motorcycle police. Lewis Lapham (Harper's Magazine Oct. 2005)
"When fascism comes to America it will be wrapped in the
flag, carrying a cross." Sinclair Lewis (1935)
Although this may be a bleak assessment, the tea parties, the political parties, rigged
elections, unstable financial system, the compromised media, the shortsighted corporations, the military-industrial
complex, a gridlocked Congress and secretive government will likely keep us on our
disastrous path toward apocalypse. There
is not much reason to think that the system is self-correcting.
All the charts in Limits to Growth seen
to show [collapse] nearly inevitable, since we didn't take our foot off
the gas when we had the chance. And the seeming solidity of our
civilization could be illusory. As Diamond shows with abundant example,
"one of the main lessons to be learned from the collapses of the Maya,
Anasazi, Easter Islanders, and those other past societies is that a
society's steep decline may begin only a decade or two after the
society reaches its peak numbers, wealth and power." (in fact, that's
exactly when you'd expect it to happen, because that peak wealth
usually means peak impact on the environment). We're overleveraged in
ways that resemble those past civilizations. In fact, they were pikers
compared to us: the Anasazi may have died out when the climate shifted,
but they didn't make it happen. And if our societies start to tank,
we'll be in worse shape than those who came before. For one thing, our
crisis is global, so there's no place to flee. For another, most of us
don't know how to do very much - in your standard collapse scenario,
it's nice to know how to grow wheat. From Eaarth
by Bill McKibbon
Democracy didn't come across on the Mayflower. Indeed not. Nor with the Niña nor
Santa Maria. Certainly not. Democracy was here. It was in full flower.
It was rampant. It was all over. All nations were free, and that
includes the buffalo nation, that includes the fish nations and the
nations of trees. They were all free. That's what was here. Not to say
that people always got along. That's why we had great councils to keep
the peace. And that's what the Haudenosauneeshone leadership is about.
We are not actually chiefs. Chief is an English word. We are hoyaneh,
which means the peacemakers. We keep the peace. That's what the
leadership is about. That's our work, that's our job. To keep the peace
and promote peace. I think people wonder about Native leaders and what
we do. Some of the activities we're involved in carry us to many places
in the world, and our leaders have always been on the move.Oren
Lyons - the ice is melting.
It is clear to anyone paying attention that we have damaged
the climate beyond repair, climate disasters will become
increasingly more severe, food shortages will be widespread as a
result of drought and accelerating desertification, mass migrations,
widespread violence and war is likely.
Population pressure and lifestyle
are the roots of environmental degradation.
Recent collapse of the environment are plain to see in Haiti, Darfur, and others. Republicans are wrong in all of their population policies. Face it, there is no
other habitable planet. Climate change, accompanied by
extinction events, will cause massive dislocations of, mainly poor
people. Republicans, always in denial, refuse to mitigate the damage.
Massive immigration is inevitable.
We were warned in the 70's when computer simulations were done
to determine what might be the
Limits to Growth for the planet. Results, which today are right on
track, indicated that the economy would reach a plateau and then
begin a decline. What was not considered in that simulation, was
climate change. In 2005 the Stern
Report estimated that "the costs of climate
change, if not addressed, will be equivalent to losing 5 percent
(and potentially as much as 20 percent) of the global gross domestic
product (GDP) 'each year, now and forever'. Hundreds of millions of
people could be threatened with hunger, water shortages, and severe
economic deprivation. Climate change, Stern wrote, is the 'greatest
market failure the world has ever seen'. (From Technology Review,
July/August 2011). Economic growth will peak and then decline.
In August, 2011 a number of notables including James Hanson,
Naomi Klein, Bill McKibbon
protested outside the White House against the Keystone Pipeline
which is designed to transport oil from Canadian tar sands to the Gulf
of Mexico. Hansen, a NASA climate scientist, has said that approval of
the pipeline is "game
over for the environment".
Republican racism, greed, hostility and subservience to the wealthy, makes hypocrisy of their 'religion'.
It doesn’t take much work for a denier to become an “expert”. Comparing most prominent 224 climate deniers (red) to 224 leading climate scientists (blue). Size is number of lit citations, horizontal axis is articles published, vertical is media coverage. https://t.co/6tGfCWpDZ1pic.twitter.com/Bjv1iT5VXW
Climate damage is settled
science: and Republicans, since they
care more about money than survival, and
represent large energy interests, are in
denial. (When the Arctic ice caps melt, just think... we can drill for
even more oil there.) It is well established that "losses
in biodiversity are occurring globally at all levels". Global warming is real and the
consequences are occurring more rapidly than the climate models
predict. Glaciers are melting fast and that can dry out rivers that
make much of the planet arable. Expect weird weather, food
shortages, desertification, more migration, species extinction.
Canada’s biggest science agency has an internal document,
introduced to some staff by NRC’s former president days before he left his
position in March, that outlines an ambitious view of NRC in 2050. And
it shows a management vision of “nation-building” technology and
world-saving achievement, all resulting from radical re-organization of
what NRC does today.
First, the scenario: Global temperatures will jump by four
degrees Celsius by 2025, the document foretells, making regions near
the equator uninhabitable for months at a time.One billion people will
be in refugee camps or wandering the Earth, looking for a place to
live. The world will have 100 super-cities of more than 30 million
people, with tremendous strain on resources and health.
Everyone searches for a “global conditioner” for the
climate. (From the Ottawa
Citizen 9/14/2016)
It gets worse: NASA climate scientist James Hansen
forecast a possible 10-foot rise in sea levels before the end of the century.
One-third of Florida's population lives below this level, as do more
that 700,000 residents of New York City. So do millions in major
coast cities. That would force evacuation of hundreds of millions.
Already police are being militarized in preparation for
popular uprisings by gangs with automatic weapons. Without wiser
policy, nuclear war is probable. That will be
the end.
"We must choose, and choose soon,
either for or against the further evolution of the human spirit. It is
for us, in the generation that turned the corner of the millennium, to
apply whatever knowledge we have, in all humility but with all due
speed, and to try to learn more as quickly as possible. It is for us,
much more than for any previous generation, to become serious about the
human future and to make choices that will be weighed not in a decade
or a century but in the balances of geological time. It is for us, with
all our stumbling, and in the midst of our dreadful confusion, to try
to disengage the tangled wing." (The
Tangled Web: Melvin Konner, 2002: pg 488)