Fifteen Years Later, Citizens United Defined the 2024 Election The influence of wealthy donors and dark money was unprecedented. Much of it would have been illegal before the Supreme Court swept away long-established campaign finance rules.
(1/14/2025)
I don't care who does the electing, as long as I get to do the nominating.
Boss Tweed
I consider it completely unimportant who in the party will vote, or how;
but what is extraordinarily important is this - who will count the votes, and how.Joseph Stalin 1879-1953 Soviet dictator
In the United States, our findings
indicate, the majority does not rule -- at least not in the causal
sense of actually determining policy outcomes. When a majority of
citizens disagrees with economic elites and/or with organized interests, they generally lose.
Moreover, because of the strong status quo bias built into the U.S.
political system, even when fairly large majorities of Americans favor
policy change, they generally do not get it. Gilens
and Page
Republicans want to make it harder for you to vote and easier for them to cheat. Look at what you are seeing now in Georgia. For four year they have embraced the big lie and election denialism. They are trying to put election deniers in key positions. Our job is to stop them. pic.twitter.com/MsGmcC4lCA
As the 2024 election approaches, state legislatures continue to propose and enact laws that expose our election system
to partisan disruption and manipulation. These laws ultimately increase the risk of subversion-that is,
a declared outcome that does not reflect the true choice of the voters.
They also abandon long-standing principles of nonpartisan election administration and instead allow for - or even encourage - dysfunction,
misinformation, confusion, or manipulation by partisan actors. A Democracy Crisis In The Making: December 2023 Year-End Update
Election officials have become prime targets of those purveying the Big Lie that the 2020 presidential race was "stolen."
A new Brennan Center poll of local election officials shows how damaging these sustained attacks have been.
Among the dire results: 77 percent feel that threats against local election officials are increasing, and 30 percent know of one or more who have quit at least in part due to safety concerns.
They also fear that conspiracy theories will infect impartial election administration.
All levels of government must act now to protect our elections and the people who run them.
Brennan Center (3/10/2022)
In early February, a Brennan Center for Justice report detailed:
"Thus far this year, thirty-three states have introduced, prefiled, or carried over 165 bills to restrict voting access. These proposals primarily seek to: (1) limit mail voting access; (2) impose stricter voter ID requirements; (3) slash voter registration opportunities; and (4) enable more aggressive voter roll purges. These bills are an unmistakable response to the unfounded and dangerous lies about fraud that followed the 2020 election."
On Feb. 24, the center updated its account to reveal that "as of February 19, 2021, state lawmakers have carried over, prefiled, or introduced 253 bills with provisions that restrict voting access in 43 states."
Voter Suppression Is Grand Larceny
I warned about this 9 months ago speaking with @JoyAnnReid@MSNBC. "The endgame of election denial is not about claiming that this or that election was corrupt. The endgame is that we shouldn't have elections." At 10:00 in the clip:https://t.co/juXd5qHyqFhttps://t.co/MrOt1nA2we
[COMMENTARY] We Told You So: The MAGA Plot to Dismantle the American Voting System From Within https://t.co/q9cH8Oivr8— HillReporter.com (@HillReporter) June 1, 2022
We don't spend enough time talking about how profoundly craven the Republican's attack on voting is https://t.co/D2MnTb4shN— Molly Jong-Fast (@MollyJongFast) May 8, 2021
We cannot allow billionaires to determine the outcome of our elections.
republicans are going to try to steal our next election.
They'll refuse to certify Biden electoral votes from certain states and get the election thrown to the House where they represent more states and will vote for trump.
They have not and will not stop their insurrection.
— Richard E Russell #IStandWithUkraine (@Elwood_R) February 24, 2024
The Trump campaign tried to organize & submit phony slates of electors to try & steal the last election. That's what voter fraud looks like! pic.twitter.com/EfhZwAyz0L
US elections do not meet
international standards and have been getting worse. Our two party
system and the rest of our established institutions are all
anti-democratic. Expensive campaign financing is mostly for media: an example of media extortion.
Even the simplest reforms, like the ones we need for
trustworthy elections , are not up for discussion. Major issues are not discussed much. Dialog is confrontational.
Election denial is a direct assault on democracy by a right wing, minority Party, the GOP,
assisted by the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court demolished the Voting Rights Act,
so Republican States again suppressed voters mostly along racial lines, gerrymandered to disenfranchise minorities.
SCOTUS decisions on campaign finance and Citizens United
allowed big, dark money into elections,
and they loosened laws on corruption.
SCOTUS equated money with speech, but the difference is money corrupts.
The Electoral College elects the President by States, not by the people.
The Supreme Court will hear a case that could allow State legislators to over ride voters.
This could be fixed by the National Popular Vote, which would assure the President would be elected
by the popular vote.
Russia helped Trump's election and benefited magnificently from his Presidency.
Not only does Trump admire Putin, it appears he intended to use the authoritarian's playbook to
become dictator for life.
Trump tried mightily to overturn the 2020 election,
changed high level Defence and DOJ officials to place loyalists in positions to overthrow the government.
He was recorded threatening Georgia election official to get more votes.
He made up and broadcast the big lie that he won the election.
Seven GOP States put up their own slate of electors,
forged documents to make Trump the election winner so they could inform VP Mike Pence that the real electors were the GOP. On January 6 Pence could throw the election to Trump, the insurrection was a part of the plan.
On 1/6 there was an actual insurrection.
Court cases challenging election results in many States were thrown out, some of his lawyers were sanctioned for their part.
Expensive recounts changed no election counts.
His agents intimidated and threatened poll workers.
The coup continues with efforts to replace election workers with Trump loyalists.
New voting laws in Republican States will have the effect of suppressing the vote.
Florida has formed a special police force for the polls.
The insurrection continues with replacement of regular poll workers with partisans.
Many recounts and the CyberNinjas long Arizona effort changed nothing.
Trump's big lie should be seen as information warfare intended to sow doubt about elections.
Three generals wrote that the military too is polarized and may support Trump next time.
That way Trump's dream of becoming dictator for life could come true.
New laws in GOP States allow legislatures to over-ride the actual vote.
Voters don't matter to the GOP, an unpopular minority.
The threat continues as Republicans oppose efforts to allow real elections.
This may be the end of US democracy and the republic.
It's no accident that CPAC is meeting in Hungary or that Fox News broadcasts its propaganda.
Rachel #Maddow nails Trump's election denial motives, "Why would you try to get everybody in your party to say that election results don't count? It's so that the idea that elections don't count becomes the operating principle of the Republican Party." pic.twitter.com/Kz3OntcWWG
BREAKING: Trump attorney Cleta Mitchell caught on tape outlining her plan to suppress Gen Z voters, stop early voting, limit votes from overseas, and other anti-democratic schemes.
An anti-American plan targeting critical battleground states for the next presidential election.
Representative government is in crisis today, partly because it has lost, in the course of time,
all institutions that permitted the citizens' actual participation,
and partly because it is now gravely affected by the disease from which the party system suffers:
bureaucratization and the two parties' tendency to represent nobody except the party machines.
Hannah Arendt (1970)
"The dismal theorem of political science --- that all the skills leading to the rise to power tend to unfit people to exercise it.
While there are some exceptions to this principle, there are a deplorable number of good examples.
A person rises to power by pushing the other contenders down, in some cases by murder, frequently by deceit, and even in democratic societies by being more persuasive that the competitors.
Persuasiveness is not always related to the capacity to live up to the persuasion."
Kenneth E. Boulding, The World as a Total System p116.
Republicans are planning to subvert future elections. They tried to overturn the election results in court in 2020 and overthrow them at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. Republicans will try again in 2022. If they fail, they will try again in 2024.https://t.co/TW2VDSoKBg
If you think you're witnessing any voter suppression, please visit https://t.co/44G0U53M0U to report it to our team of voting rights attorneys who are on standby to help and use this information to inform litigation. pic.twitter.com/T9etDXZolm
There have been 8,000 threats against members of Congress since January 6th, election workers across the country are leaving their positions out of fear for their safety,
there are over 400 bills introduced in states to stop the freedom to vote. The stakes have never been higher.
Phone the United States Capitol switchboard at (202) 224-3121. A switchboard operator will connect you directly with the Senate office you request. Ask your Senators to: Defend Democracy & your Right to VOTE by supporting For the People Act & Restore the Voting Rights Act
0/20 This election will determine the future of our republic. Here are some principles for the preservation of freedom that I wrote nearly four years ago, when all of this was beginning. I share them again now in admiration of Americans who protest for justice and work for truth.
A healthy democracy would make Election Day a national holiday so more people would vote. A democracy besieged by fascists would face shorter voting hours, fewer voting days, fewer voting methods and even a ban on giving water to people standing in line to vote.
NEW VIDEO: Republicans know their ideas aren't popular, which is why they've lost the popular vote in all but 1 election in the last 32 years. So after losing in 2020, they're trying to make it even harder to vote across the country.
Not satisfied with wrecking the post office, casting doubt on mail-in ballots, suing all over the place to suppress votes, now the Trumpian plan is to intimidate in person voters. So much so that the NAACP is organizing volunteers to escort voters into their polling place.
The Office of the Director of National Intelligence's decision to cancel all election security briefings for the Congress is a shocking abdication of its responsibility to keep Congress informed.
I am not at all certain we will be able to conduct a free and fair election in November or have a peaceful transition of presidential power in January. We are edging toward a cultural civil war,
only this time we are not lucky: Abraham Lincoln is not the president.
Tom Friedman, New York Times (6/4/2020)
An Angolan friend of Joe Wilson remarked: "One
candidate loses the popular vote by over 500,000 ballots, but his brother is governor of
the one state where the outcome is too close to call. The effort to
count the ballots is disrupted by the Washington staffs of elected
representatives from the candidate's party, and the court that
ultimately adjudicates the outcome is made up largely by people
appointed by the candidate's father. Sounds a lot like an election in
Africa."; Joe Wilson: Politics
of Truth; pg 281.
Chief Justice John Roberts Jr 6/25/2013:
"There is No Denying - That the Conditions that Originally Justified these Measures - No longer Characterize Voting in the Covered Jurisdictions."
Wrong!
States and Counties - with Histories of Racial Discrimination - were Required to ... pic.twitter.com/BlAzMZYRqp
Voter suppression the new GOP strategy:
Better bring some identification - and not just any identification,
official though it may be - if you plan to vote in
Republican-controlled states. However,
if you contribute tens of millions of dollars to sway an election on
Republicans behalf, the party will fight to keep your identity a
secret. Voter suppression the new GOP strategy" Harold
Meyerson, 11/19/2013
SIX STATES SUE USPS FOR ELECTION INTERFERENCE The slowing or impeding of lawful ballots is a Federal offense.https://t.co/pdrfs6Z9ci
Iran, not noted for its democracy, has its
elections on a holiday. If the US did this working people would have a lot easier
time voting. What does it say that we have not done this ?
1. Hide COVID-19 data from voters. 2. Make mail-in voting impossible for many voters. 3. Spread disinformation via social media. 4. Solicit and receive illegal foreign aid. 5. If all else fails, provoke a new crisis to distract voters.
“As I have said for many years, I happen not to
believe that within the framework of the two-party system, the Democratic Party
and Republican Party, that we are going to be able to bring about the
real changes in this country that are needed to benefit the vast
majority of our people. Essentially, it is my view that the leadership
of the Democratic Party and Republican Party are tied to big money
interests, and that neither of these parties will ever represent the
people in this country who are demanding the real changes that have to
take place.” – Bernie
Sanders
We now know that a top Justice Department official tried to use the department's power to help overturn the results of the election, without any basis in fact or law and at the clear urging of then-president Donald Trump. This was an attempted coup.https://t.co/cApJB6M8S8
If politicians wanted better turnout and fair elections, we would have them.
Election Day should be a national holiday. Could be on Veteran's Day to remind everyone what they thought they were fighting for. It is too much to ask people to take time off work especially if lines have been made deliberately long or there are few working voting machines as happened in Georgia.
Behind the scenes, hidden from public view,
corporations and big donors actually pick candidates from which voters choose.
They oppose democracy and block Constitutional checks and balances,
but Congress responds to them, not the people.
We are really only allowed two parties, since added ones would likely be spoilers, yet another way to rig an election for a minority party.
It will be that way until we have Ranked Choice Voting. Maine learned that lesson from Governor Paul Lepage. After a referendum and a subsequent Constitutional struggle, they finally got RCV.
The 2 party system is not part of the Constitution and is, itself, part of election problems. A third party is a spoiler, may take votes from the majority party, and sometimes is a sham.
Ranked choice voting should be standard to fix it.
The assumption that two parties are the only legitimate
competitors is one of the most effective techniques to assure that
the status quo will not be challenged. We have dysfunctional
government because neither party wants the other to accomplish
anything. Better voting techniques, like range
voting, would enable multi-party competition. The dialog would
improve. Minor parties are, right now, spoilers and can only
make prospects for their opponents even brighter.; We do not have
a peace party, and continue to support an empire
in decline that is bankrupting us.
Since voting in person in a pandemic is a health risk, absentee paper ballots are in order, they are also more efficient. Republicans, including Connecticut Trump followers, resist this even if it puts voters lives at risk.
Wisconsin Republicans, assisted by the Courts, made sure that in-person voting was required disregarding the pandemic. Because poll workers are elderly, there were few of them, resulting in long lines to vote. The 'pro-life' GOP would put lives at risk to vote.
SCOTUS, having allowed dark money into elections, turned a blind eye to gerrymandering, has all but obliterated the Voting Rights Act.
Candidates tend to change their positions depending on the
venue. Once elected, may not do what they said they would.
(etch-a-sketch) The best we
can hope for is, when a candidate announces his agenda, he will have the
integrity to act on it. The worst case is increasingly likely: we will get a strong
man head of state who is above the law,
corrupt, and capable of destroying us all. Are we there
yet ?
Qualifications are irrelevant (Bush is
an example.) If you were hiring for a high office, you would look for
someone who speaks well, has traveled widely, has diplomatic
expertise, academic excellence, and a distinguished record.
(Bush had none of these. Thanks Republicans.); After reviewing many
such resumes, you might find an acceptable candidate. That's not how we
do it. Trump and his cabinet prove that vetting is not part of the political process.
Candidates for high office should be screened: background checked, tax returns required,
conflicts of interest resolved,
Conventions
accomplish little since the candidate has been selected well in
advance.
The GOP knows a real election would be a disaster for them, so they gerrymander, purge
voter rolls, make voters wait for hours in long lines to vote, spend
massive cash to buy media, flawed election
mechanics, fail to vet or background check candidates.
Candidates, to a large extent, are not really selected in primaries.
They are funded by wealthy donors well before the primaries for very
high
stakes donations. That explains why both parties candidates are
from almost identical backgrounds, why they are so dedicated to the
corporate
interest, and also why the US
is more a plutocracy
than a democracy.;
Electing candidates from dynastic families creates massive conflict
of interest. (See Bush.)
Republicans also put up celebrity candidates with little
experience in public office, who most likely can be
persuaded to act in the interest of their donors.
US elections are rigged well before the votes are cast in a
variety of ways: party insider dealings, loaded media,
gerrymandering, suppressed voter registration, large moneyed interests,
primaries where special interests can dominate, strange differences
in state procedures, plain dirty tricks, misleading attack ads,
rigged voting machines, outright
miscounting, or even partisan court decisions... and so on.
As we saw in Florida and Ohio, partisan bureaucrats can rig
elections wholesale by controlling voter registration lists,
dirty tricks, manipulating media, allocation of election machines, hacking machines to fix vote
totals, and, as Republicans are doing
in many States, making
it harder to vote.;
The person who manages to get 'elected' is the one who gets to
set an agenda...whether most of the people
agree with him or not. Some politicians regularly change their positions
depending on who funds them.
Is it coincidence that terror
alerts occur just before elections ?
Since use of nuclear weapons are suicidal for humanity, the next war could be
with cyber weapons and foreign infiltration such as the one
Russians waged to elect Trump.
They were surprisingly successful and benefited immensely.
It's probably not over. at least until nuclear exchange.
States will soon begin the process of redrawing their electoral districts. And this time, it's on all of us to use our voices and demand that redistricting is fair and transparent so that we have #FairMaps and elections for the next decade. Join us today: https://t.co/a4ObthHF7K
The Constitution was written to protect slavery. It gave rural States more powerful votes, so the Senate, the Presidency, and the resulting Supreme Court can be elected without the popular vote which is why they are Republican right now.
The absence of a federal right to vote coupled with
the Supreme Court's inclination to value procedure over real-world
voter behavior has dramatic consequences for America's elections.
Voter-registration requirements are convoluted. Voter rolls are
purged chaotically. Ballot design is unregulated and amateurish.
Polling hours are haphazard. Voting equipment ranges from high-tech
to derelict. Vote-counting and recounting systems are unsystematic.
In 1964, the Supreme Court proclaimed that "no right is more
precious in a free country than that of having a voice in the
election of those who make the laws under which, as good citizens,
we must live." But under the decisions of this Court, voters can
perhaps be forgiven for feeling occasionally more like mice in a
maze than like citizens of a democracy. Victoria Bassetti, from Electoral
Dysfunction
Republicans could not repeal the McCain-Feingold campaign finance legislation, or get rid of the Voting Rights Act. But the Roberts Court took care of the problem through constitutional interpretation.
Constitutional Rot Reaches the Supreme Court (10/5/2018)
Paperless electronic voting machines "cannot be made secure," according to draft recommendations issued by NIST that advises the U.S. Election Assistance Commission.
“There is only one issue in this country,” former
MSNBC commentator Cenk Uygur told Netroots Nation, in June 2011. “Campaign finance
reform.” (From the preface to Lawrence Lessig's book Republic
Lost. which is free to download)
The first phase of US elections is an auction
to see which candidates click their heels for the highest bidders. This makes wealthy
campaign donors the gate-keepers. Their interests are sharply different
than most; peoples. See this Lawrence
Lessig Ted talk for a fuller explanation.
BREAKING: New analysis finds that 465 billionaires had pumped $881,000,000 into the 2022 federal midterm elections by October.
That's 27x more than they contributed before Citizens United was decided.
"Elections are run by the public relations industry.
Its primary task is commercial advertising, which is designed
to undermine markets by creating uninformed consumers who will make
irrational choices -- the exact opposite of how markets are supposed to work, but certainly
familiar to anyone who has watched television." Noam
Chomsky, Because We Say So pg 66.
In essence, broadcasters are now profiteering from a
vicious circle of corruption: Politicians are beholden to big donors
because campaigns are so expensive, and campaigns are so expensive
because they're fought through television ads. The more cash that
chases limited airtime, the more the ads will cost, and the more
politicians must lean on deep-pocketed patrons. In short, the dirtier
the system, the better for the bottom line at TV stations and cable
systems." Tim Dickenson, Rolling
Stone, 8/6/2012
US media
is interested only in the candidates who
raise the most money because, for them, elections are a profit
tsunami. Since a large part of campaigning is spent on
advertising, the broadcasters and other news outlets are strongly
conflicted to favor the fund raising winner. The candidate(s) with
the most dollar votes are the most likely primary winner for the
two major parties. Third parties are, using our election
procedures, spoilers, so it is counter-productive to vote for
them. Range voting would fix this.
Media, covering the election as if it
were a horserace, marginalizes candidates who are not raising a lot of money, declare
the largest fund-raisers winners, and pretty much force out lesser
known candidates (or those who do not agree with the party orthodoxy) with
very few votes cast. Since media conglomerates are owned by oligarchs,
have been better funded by Republicans, their right-wing bias is obviously to Republicans. The agenda is not for people
and the Federal budget proves it. It is
corporate. Money sometimes is speech, but in large quantities it can also be exceptionally
corrupting. Citizens United needs to be
overturned.
U.S. media selects the issues to be
addressed in the election discussion. Most often the news is
concentrated on the certifiably trivial. It has determined that the fiscal cliff
is the problem, not healthcare,
education, media concentration, election fraud, income distribution, falling pay
scales, loss of benefits, disappearing pensions, empire
building, runaway military spending, nuclear proliferation, the
prison-industrial complex, torture,
renditions, climate change,
a partisan Supreme Court, money-driven
Congress, or an uncontrolled President that
threatens the Constitution.
"Issues, never a strong suit in our
politics, are seldom alluded to. Only money - who raised how much and from whom -
interested the media, and the politicians." Gore Vidal, Point to
Point Navigation.
Election commissions are being kept weak by political
leaders who want the freedom to skirt rules without consequences. The
two major federal agencies should be in the forefront of fighting for
honest elections. Instead, they have little mandate, vigor, or visibility.
At the Federal Election Assistance Commission, all five commissioner
posts were vacant during the 2012 campaign. The Obama administration
failed to overcome Republican obstruction to staffing and funding. A similar situation
existed at the Federal Election Commission, where the terms of five of the
six commissioners expired by the end of 2012. The commission, which
focuses on funding, brought just a tenth of the number of official
actions during the year compared to 2008": Presidential Puppetry:
Andrew Kreig
During the last German election, there was a lot of talk of potential Russian interference, you know, it's gonna swing the election.
Well, it turns out there was foreign interference, but it wasn't Russian. It was a combination of the Berlin office of Facebook and a media company
in the U.S., which works for Trump, Le Pen, Netanyahu, other nice guys. They used Facebook in Berlin to get a demographic analysis of
parts of the population to allow them to microtarget ads to individuals in favor of AfD, the neo-Nazi party, which may have been a factor in their
unexpectedly high vote in the election. This was reported in Bloomberg Businessweek. This was a real case of electoral manipulation but somehow
it doesn't make the headlines. (
Noam Chomsky)
Seen from the global South, U.S. elections inspire jokes about the deeply flawed democracy that the United States
seeks to impose on the rest of the world. When democratically elected governments try to challenge the global capitalist system,
they become targets for military intervention, coups d'etat, and furious attempts to destabilize their political and economic systems.
So defects of the U.S. electoral system become glaring: scheduling election days on workdays rather than national holidays or Sundays:
buying politicians through campaign contributions and other financial support;
creation of false consciousness through manipulation of the media; and apathy, non-participation, intimidation,
and exclusion of U.S. voters through complex voter registration requirements, insufficient polling places and staffing,
and similar maneuvers that discourage voters from voting - leading in this case to Trump's so-called triumph when he received votes
from less that 25 percent of eligible voters and less that one-sixth of all citizens, lost the popular vote, and faced no run-off election.
Howard Waitzkin
Of the dirty tricks in Presidential elections, probably the worst is interference in foreign affairs to win elections: Nixon sabotaged Vietnam peace talks, Reagan held up release of Iran hostages later sealing the deal with the Iran-Contra scandal,
and now it appears that Trump had Russian help in winning his election. In the case of these corporate (Republican) Presidents, we get a large military buildup, partially paid for by cuts to social programs, followed by a war often in their first term.
Only sociopaths can qualify.
Reality
Winner went to jail for releasing a classified document that
confirmed that Russians
interfered in the 2016
election. The Trump
administration does not acknowledge the problem, Mitch McConnell
blocked action to guard against it, so we can be exposed to foreign
interference in the future as well.
Evgeny Popov, the host of 60 Minutes, the most popular state TV program in
Russia as of 2018, is defiant about the findings in the Mueller
report. Popov tells me: 'Soon, we will help you elect Trump once
again. Just like the last time. Get ready!' Julia
Davis
Platform
We should be voting for a platform
that reflects the will of the people,
and candidates should be required to implement it. Comparing agendas though, Republicans
are, as Thomas Frank wrote so well, not only voting against their own self-interest, their climate denial is a suicide pact for life
on the planet. So is the forever war.
Medicare for All is important in a pandemic, a Green New Deal could mitigate the destruction of the planet, international cooperation is necessary for both, free public K-16 public education could improve democracy, productivity and election results, a progressive wealth tax could damp down extreme inequality and pay for the general welfare. It's not easy to see any of these things on the horizon. Republicans claim they're socialist, part of their attack on democracy.
It's not looking good for November. It may be the last chance you'll ever have to vote out Republicans, enablers of a Fascist leader who is attacking and corroding democracy just as other dictators do.
. @marceelias gives us a blueprint for the most important thing we can do
"A few days before the November 2004 election, Jimmy
Carter was asked what would happen if, instead of flying to Zambia
or Venezuela or East Timor, his widely respected international
election-monitoring team was invited to turn its attention to the
United States. His answer was stunningly blunt. Not only would the
voting system be regarded as a failure, he said, but the
shortcomings were so egregious the Carter Center would never agree
to monitor an election there in the first place...The American
political system wouldn't measure up to any sort of international
standards, for several reasons."; From the first page of
"Steal
this Vote" by Andrew
Gumbel (Winner of the Project Censored Award.)
Trump: If it's easy to vote, Republicans will never win: "Things they had in [the bill] were crazy," Trump told "Fox & Friends". "They had...levels of voting that if you ever agreed to it you'd never have a Republican elected in this country again."
Florida Republicans, like their counterparts in other states and in Washington, D.C., are becoming increasingly comfortable with the perks of minority rule, like the ability to disregard what the majority of voters demand.
They appear to know that when you can't win on your ideas, you win by undermining democracy.
Why Are Florida Republicans So Afraid of People Voting? (8/10/2019)
privatization of our elections has occurred without
public knowledge or consent, leading to one of the most dangerous and
least understood crises in the history of American democracy. We have
actually lost the ability to verify election results. How
to Rig an Election
There's nothing in the Constitution that says there have to be only two parties.
There's nothing in the Constitution about parties at all. There's not even anything in the Constitution mandating that each congressional district have only one member and be represented by one party.
We could have a much fairer and better system with the passage of a law.
The way to do that is through multimember districts and ranked-choice voting. David Brooks: One Reform to Save America
BREAKING NEWS: Bipartisan Senate panel concludes Russia penetrated all 50 States' election systems and is poised to change vote tallies. But Trump & McConnell still block all defensive measures. Betraying national security and democracy. https://t.co/K6iUcUB1ax
'Democracy for Some, But Not for All': Report Reveals Nearly 1,700 Polling Places Closed Since Supreme Court Weakened Voting Rights Act - https://t.co/oYhXKCTvvR
Trump didn't actually win the election in 2016. He lost the election, and he was put into office because the Russians interfered.' -Former Pres. Jimmy Carter pic.twitter.com/SBZpaR6JTM
"Genuine democratic elections cannot be achieved unless a wide range of other human rights
and fundamental freedoms can be exercised on an ongoing basis without discrimination based
on race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin,
property, birth or other status, including among others disabilities, and without arbitrary and
unreasonable restrictions. They, like other human rights and democracy more broadly, cannot
be achieved without the protections of the rule of law. These precepts are recognized by human
rights and other international instruments and by the documents of numerous intergovernmental
organizations. Achieving genuine democratic elections therefore has become a matter of
concern for international organizations, just as it is the concern of national institutions, political
competitors, citizens and their civic organizations" DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNATIONAL
ELECTION OBSERVATION. The Carter Center
When Eisenhower warned of the Military Industrial Complex, he was thinking about physical weapons.
But, just as unregulated semi-automatics invented for soldiers end up going off in American schools,
it shouldn't be any kind of surprise that the weapons of information war are going off in Anglo-American votes.
Cambridge Analytica is what happens when you privatise military propaganda: Adam Ramsay (3/28/2018)
James Clapper just said on CNN that he believes the Russians have the ability, if they so choose, to actually manually change votes — in the voting machines — in 2020.
This is the second time I’ve heard this said this week.
"But delegates from the slaveholding South had another rationale for opposing the direct election method, and they had no qualms about articulating it: Doing so would be to their disadvantage." https://t.co/o4phkmvZao
"...election fraud has been a common component of
our nation's electoral history, and, in the aggregate, undermines
the only check that the people have over their leaders." from Deliver
the Vote by Tracy Campbell
When you exclude third parties from the election
process, third parties that the vast majority of Americans would
like to see in the presidential debates, your not only
denying those people the right to choose who they want to run for
president and who they want to vote for, but youre denying
the very fundamental and critical issues that, in a generative
democracy, we need to have aired in from of tens of millions of
voters.George
Farah
The immediate effect of the money-and-media election
complex is to encourage election campaigns, like those in 2012, that do
not even
begin to address the societal pathologies afflicting the people of the
United States. The trillion dollars spent annually on militarism and
war is off-limits to public review and debate. Likewise, the corporate
control of the economy and the corporate domination of government
itself get barely a nod. Stagnation, gaping economic inequality,
growing poverty, and collapsing infrastructure and social
services—major issues all—are accorded nothing more than the
market-tested drivel candidates say to get votes. The existential
threats posed by climate change and nuclear weaponry are virtually
off-limits as campaign-season issues; whole debates that are supposed
to go to the heart of domestic and global concerns pass by without
mention of them. The drug war, which has created a prison-industrial
complex so vast that the United States has a greater percentage of its
population imprisoned than any other nation in history, is not to be
mentioned—except when obviously engaged and concerned citizens force
the issue onto the ballot via the initiative process." Dollarocracy:
John Nichols and Robert W McChesney
Even the 2016 Presidential candidates agreed that elections are
rigged. But the problem is not voter fraud, it is structural: A partisan Supreme Court, Citizens United, Electoral
College, gerrymandering, fake news (mostly Republican),
voter suppression, Russian interference, dirty tricks, and other techniques effectively
impose minority rule. To put it more bluntly, Republicans cheat at elections.
For a variety of reasons favored by Republicans, the U.S. also has the lowest voter turnout of any developed country.
Because Republicans are a minority party they have to cheat at elections.
That explains why they tried to bully their way to have a citizenship question on the census.
It is why they gerrymander in States where they can.
It is why in Florida, where voters said that felons should be allowed to vote, they added a provision that required ex-felons to pay back debt before they could vote. It is why they can maintain control, even of the Presidency without the popular vote.
It is why, at every opportunity, they oppose democracy.
Reality Winner went to jail for releasing a classified document that confirmed that
Russians interfered in the 2016 election. The Trump administration does not acknowledge the problem,
Mitch McConnell has blocked action to guard against it,
so we may be exposed to foreign interference in the future as well.
The deep root of our problems is income inequality. See Lawrence
Lessig's youtube video Lesterland for
an idea of how funders influence Congress
and choose candidates well in advance. Billionaires
did win, and so did their agenda.
The two party duopoly , by
gerrymandering, voter suppression, massive cash flow, flawed election
mechanics, bought media, failed to vet or background check Presidential candidates.
Most people didn't like either of the two Presidential candidates for election 2016.
Picking the least worst assured that things will get worse, and so it did with Trump.
For all practical purposes, we are not allowed to have minor
parties, because they are spoilers. Voting for them can result
in the victory of the Party you do not like. The simple solution for
this: implement range voting in which you rank
the candidates and your second and third choices can count. A
Maine ballot initiative passed for this, and should be a model for
the nation. Lacking IRV or range voting, just hold your nose and pick the least worst.
Elections are a sham without real discussion of issues and
reliable media. Although the Russians were blamed for release of DNC
documents, there was no denial that the documents are genuine.
What they showed is that the Party selected the candidate, not the
people. We do need Wikileaks to know what government is doing.
The two party administration of debates strongly limits the range of discussion.
There was not one question about climate change in the 2016 Presidential
debates.
The FBI historically has weighed in on
elections and it always leans right. It helped
elect Nixon, Reagan in 1980, and Trump
in 2016. It
has demonstrated the political danger of the surveillance
state.
With election flaws so obvious, several Election reforms should be a priority: range voting so that
minor parties are not spoilers, universal voter registration,
vet candidates for high office before they get on the ballot including required release of tax returns,
and background check appropriate for the position sought,
roll back of Citizens United, restoration of
the Voting Rights Act, a national holiday for elections, and elimination of
he Electoral College so that the popular vote matters. We need fair elections.
Republicans govern for the elite,
not the people, and they will game the system even more to extract
wealth from the 99.9 %.
The Two Party System
"They've created a system based upon bribery. Today,
Wall Street owns our politicians, no matter which party (gang) it is -- their allegiance
is to the corporations and big business," Jesse Ventura: Democrips
and ReBloodlicans, No More Gangs in Government:
We need to re-examine the two party system. It wasn't part of
the Constitution and It is not beneficial. It produces poor candidates, results in gridlock,
and government dysfunction. Both major parties are driven by corporate cash.
Since parties run elections, there is considerable corruption
that doesn't make the news...let alone the courts. Debates are staged so that real issues are not discussed.
See the video "Unprecedented" on-line
referenced above (election 2000) for examples.
In the first years of the Bush
administration, Republicans controlled all the branches of government (press too really) and
Constitutional checks were inoperable. The
two-party system short-circuits the Constitution.
Since the Bush administration did not
appoint acceptable candidates for the Federal Election Commission, that too became
dysfunctional.
"Who thought this up – Giving a private
corporation (CNN) control of a presidential debate? In the most recent Democratic presidential
debate, CNN controlled which candidates were invited, who asked what
questions, and the location, Las Vegas – the glittering, gambling
center of America. This is a mirror image of the control Fox News
exercised during their Republican candidates’ circus. Corporatism
aside, the debate with Bernie Sanders, Hillary Clinton, Martin
O’Malley, Jim Webb and Lincoln Chafee was not a debate. With few
exceptions – most notably Hillary Clinton going after Bernie Sanders on
gun control, about which she is reborn – the stage was the setting for
a series of interview questions to each candidate by Anderson Cooper
and his colleagues." Ralph Nader (10/16/2015)
No
Debate: How the Republican and Democratic Parties Secretly Control the Presidential Debates
George Farah
Reality
Even the candidates agree that U.S.
elections are rigged.
When the Supreme Court struck
down the Voting Rights Act,
Republican States immediately went back to
strategies to suppress
voting rights: requiring documentation difficult to get, 'cleansing'
voter registration lists, and others. (See the war on drugs, or prisons,
or national security state, or
vast right-wing
conspiracy.) But Republicans also gerrymandered States so that,
along with a voter suppression effort, they gained long-term control of
the House. They have managed to control the Congress
without a majority of voters.
The Supreme Court'sCitizens
United decision guaranteed that the influence of money
in elections will be more powerful than people's votes and, if not reversed, it
will cost us our
republic. Most of the money goes to media
so you won't hear about it from broadcasters.
If it wasn't for Bush, would we have
gone to Iraq ? Would there have been an
initiative to privatize everything including Social Security,
healthcare, utilities, or even the military ?
In a real democracy, our
government would support an agenda that is democratically agreed upon. That is
NOT the case. That is why torture,
renditions, secret detention facilities, secret government, revocation
of habeas corpus, empire, war profiteering, are all more important than fixing infrastructure, health care or providing real security for
people. No US institutions are democratic.
Important issues are not discussed.
If the US was a democracy and was
influenced by its people, the US budget
would be open and transparent, since most people favor peace, we would not be building an empire, we would not torture, pre-emptive war
would be criminal (as it was found at Nuremburg.) and international law would be considered
valid. Most people favor health care
reform, more equitable income
distribution, limits on corporations
(like Walmart), US government does not work
for the people. Priorities expressed in the US budget
are the opposite of those of the people.
The large, secret, unaccountable part of government is
probably the real ruler.
Elections have little effect on policy.
Real democracy would allow
people, not oligarchs, to set the agenda, but
the likelihood of our seeing any of these things is so slim as to be non-existent.
For election 2016, we are
had to choose between two candidates that most people viewed unfavorably. Both would
continue in mostly the wrong direction because they are both beholden to big money.
The US election process needs a complete overhaul.;
The two 2016 Presidential candidates both
had mostly unfavorable ratings.
Primary elections are a Rube Goldberg
contraption that make the politically weird State of New Hampshire
one of the most influential. The Manchester Union Leader is one of
the most 'conservative' newspapers in the US. It is instrumental in
keeping the U.S. one of the most reactionary in
the world.
Iowa caucuses appear to be ideal for
arranging the outcome. Candidates
selected in the primaries are not
the best qualified. See Bush for an
example.
Candidates, to a large extent, are not
really selected in primaries. They are funded by wealthy donors well
before the primaries for very high
stakes donations. That explains why both parties candidates are
from almost identical backgrounds, why they are so dedicated to the corporate interest, and also why the US is more a plutocracy
than a democracy.;
Electing candidates from dynastic families creates massive conflict of interest. (See Bush.)
Do not underestimate the media's ability to remove candidates from
consideration and to swing elections. Remember how Reagan was
characterized as 'teflon man' because in spite of Iran-Contra
criminal activities, the mining of harbors in Nicaragua (which the
World Court ruled against the US), or the huge waste incurred in
the military buildup to counter the Soviet Union, there was never
any serious press review. Likewise media
was a cheerleader for the war in Iraq and
never looked at it critically. For example, Fox News is, for
all practical purposes, a branch of the Republican party, CNN uses 'conservative' experts, NBC was
owned by war profiteer General Electric, ABC has links to the CIA,
and so on. There is no doubt that US news is seriously compromised,
voters are not given good information, Americans are misinformed, distracted, and misled on important issues.
Concentrated corporate, right-wing; media has dumbed down information to
trivialized sound bites. Media has become, with Republican and FCC assistance,
more concentrated. This is no accident. Privatized corporate media,
has taken almost all meaningful discourse from public policy
discussion. Big media only pays attention to candidates with
buckets of money (the real election is up to the fund raisers),
discussion of issues is limited because only two
similar parties debate, voting
machines can be easily hacked, and election
apparatus is in the hands of partisans it is no wonder that our democracy is increasingly
weakened.
Worse, public policy is increasingly
determined in secret. Since the Bush
administration made secrecy
a value, there is probably not enough reliable information to support real democracy anymore.
Even the Congress is incapable of oversight for lack of
information. That, alone, can end the republic. The Patriot Act will end the possibility of
freedom for Americans.
Media expense has made serious fund raising
a requirement for members of Congress and
elections and, as a result there have been many initiatives for campaign finance
reform.; Campaign ads, like Pharma ads, look a lot like
media extortion. It's the price we pay for privatized media (and health care). The
public media sector is all but non-existent. Candidates are forced to
spend large amounts of time on fund raising.
The two party monopoly on elections
effectively suppresses public dialog. Issues discussed often are of
little importance: for example Bush's (lack of)
military experience, Kerry's war record or climate destruction.
Even though it is clear that better voting procedures could be used, they are not
up for discussion. Probably because they would interfere with the two
party monopoly. If it comes to a choice between parties or
the Constitution, the parties need to
be checked. For all practical
purposes, we are not really allowed
to have more than two parties.
It is all but impossible for third parties to be other than
spoilers. We could change that by implementing range
voting.
Presidential debates are run by the two
major parties
and everyone else is excluded. On major issues, such as
the war in Iraq or healthcare,;
there is little difference between the parties reducing voting to a matter of personalities.
People have no say in substantive issues. During the Republican Bush years we have seen that the party that
controls all three branches can trump Constitutional checks. Two party dominance is
official public policy.
The US has the highest prison populations per
capita in the world. Gary
Webb reported on CIA complicit drug
smuggling into Los Angeles and he was for all practical purposes fired from the San Jose
Mercury News for doing it. Not only was this a branch of the Iran-Contra illegal war, but it had the effect of making a large
number of the (mostly democratic voting) minorities
ineligible to vote. In many states felons can't vote. One tenth of African Americans
are disenfranchised.
...over the past twenty years, we have let
corporations into our polling places, locations so sacred to democracy that in
many states even international election monitors and reporters are
banned. With the implementation of "black box voting" (the use of
electronic voting machines), these corporations are recording our
votes, compiling and tabulating them, and then telling us the total
numbers - and doing it all using "proprietary" hardware and
software that we cannot observe, cannot audit, and cannot control.
If the vote-counting corporation says candidate X or candidate Y
won the vote, we have no means of rebutting that, and they have no
way of proving it. We're asked simply to trust them. From Thom
Hartman's book
Threshold pg 210.;
Our most serious risk of election fraud is from voting
machines. They use unauditable proprietary software,
are not secured, and are
manufactured by right-wing partisans. To have real elections we need
minmal standards for voting mechanisms security and auditability. All
things considered, it is reasonable to conclude that U.S. elections are
not legitimate...nor is its government.
A google search for
Republican Dirty Tricks turns up 131,000 results. Underhanded
behavior has been standard operating procedure since Nixon, and his
proteges have used it extensively. See this.
The documentary film "Hacking Democracy", originally broadcast
on HBO, is being released today on DVD. The film takes a
nonpartisan, clear-eyed look at the secrecy, cronyism, and
incompetence of elections in present-day America as it captures a
citizen's movement intent on taking back elections--and democracy
itself.
For me personally, I know that talking to legislators who have seen
this movie is like night and day compared to those who haven't seen
it. The film definitely makes the "light bulb" go on as far as the
vulnerability of electronic voting systems. I wish I could afford
to send a copy to every legislator in the U.S.
Christine Jennings (Florida CD-13 contested race) has said, for
example, that she has seen the movie twice. A local candidate in
Volusia County who saw the film demanded a ballot inspection of her
race (full manual recounts aren't allowed in Florida) and did
public records requests to our supervisor of elections to get
information on the memory cards used, something a typical candidate
would normally not think of doing.
The DVD, available at HackingDemocracy.com,
contains "extra"
segements not included in the original film, including great
footage from Riverside California (Michelle Townsend); Cuyahoga
County, Ohio; Volusia County, Florida; Glades County, Florida; and
more.
On the website, you can also see fascinating TV footage of the
trial and sentencing of the Ohio election workers in Cuyahoga
County. Russ Michaels, one of the directors and producers of
"Hacking Democracy," says the website will be adding more footage
all the time from their vast store of film segments from elections
around the country.
VerifiedVoting.org is
a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization championing reliable and
publicly verifiable elections. Founded by Stanford University
Computer Science Professor David Dill, the organization supports a
requirement for voter-verified paper ballots for elections,
allowing voters to inspect individual permanent records of their
ballots and election officials to conduct meaningful audits and
recounts.See this link
also.
Dr. Steven Freeman of the University of Pennsylvania presents
a statistical analysis of the disparity between exit polling data and
reported votes in three critical states, including Ohio. He
concludes that the odds of these disparities being accounted for by
chance is around one in one thousand for each state and around one
in two hundred and fifty million for the three states taken as a
whole.; The impact of this study is that there needs to be an
investigation of the possibility of voting fraud in Ohio, and the
nation as a whole, in addition to a recount.https://www.ilcaonline.org/freeman.pdf
Voting machines are not the only problem though. Candidates may
have a message that people like, but once elected they feel free to
shape the agenda any way they want. Our Congress is taking action
that only Corporations could support, and they are not being held
accountable. Intense, well funded lobbying diverts Congress
from an agenda that benefits people to one that is pretty much
written by corporations. (One of the dictionary definitions of
Fascism is control of the government by corporations.) Since media
is a corporate offspring, people have no real
way to shape the agenda. Mainstream media is mostly about
distraction. Here are the common media
techniques for suppression of the truth: https://www.dabney.com/wacomuseum/library/martin1.html
It is public information that the US CIA has rigged elections in
many other countries. Since our President is the son of a former
CIA director, brother of the Governor of the State of Florida, are
you surprised that there is election
fraud in the US as well ?
If you are not discouraged
by all this,
you can register to vote here.
If you experience problems at the polls this season, please call the Election Protection
hotline for help and information.
The number is 1-866-OUR-VOTE (1-866-687-8683). Download the
flyer